Welcome! This is your first free article. Get more free articles when you sign up with your email.


“Fundamentally flawed two-hander”

Jessica Phillippi’s Illegal offers two stories in one, both based on true stories. The first is a semi-autobiographical account of Phillipi’s battle with the home office to secure her right to remain in the UK. The second is that of Claudia Patricia Gomez Gonzalez, the Guatemalan 20-year-old who was shot dead at the US border in May 2018.

You can see what she’s trying to do – offer up these two stories alongside one another in order to interrogate the injustice of immigration systems on both sides of the Atlantic – but she does it really clumsily. Her script flicks monotonously from one story to the other in awkward chunks, and she repeatedly slips into bizarrely cheery rhyming couplets.

It’s more than a little cringeworthy, and there’s undeniably something uncomfortable about the way Illegal places the two stories side-by-side, as if there’s anything remotely similar to a privileged US actor trying to get a UK visa, and a Guatemalan 20-year-old struggling to cross the Rio Grande.

Heather Knudtson’s production for Scandal Theatre and Riotbox admittedly makes good use of a difficult space, dangling streams of paper from the ceiling, but it can’t fix a fundamentally flawed show.

Sea Sick review at CanadaHub, Edinburgh – ‘eloquent and galvanising’


Related to this Review

Sea SickSea Sick

Production Details
Production nameIllegal
VenueUnderbelly Cowgate
StartsAugust 1, 2019
EndsAugust 26, 2019
Running time1hr
AuthorJessica Phillippi
DirectorHeather Knudtson
Set designerHeather Knudtson
CastElena Larios, Jessica Phillippi
ProducerRiotbox Productions, Scandal Theatre
VerdictFundamentally flawed two-hander about two separate struggles with immigration
Add New Comment
You must be logged in to comment.
Fergus Morgan

Fergus Morgan

Fergus Morgan

Fergus Morgan

Your subscription helps ensure our journalism can continue

Invest in The Stage today with a subscription starting at just £3.98
The Stage
© Copyright The Stage Media Company Limited 2020
Linked In