Welcome! This is your first free article. Get more free articles when you sign up with your email.


“Bruce's norris' harrowing but cynical new play”

The new play by Pulitzer-winner and liberal-bubble-busting Bruce Norris asks: what should we do with paedophiles? Incarcerate, rehabilitate, or pity them? Care for them or kill them?

Set in a group home for registered sex offenders, there is barely a moment in Downstate that is not hideously, gut-twistingly gripping. It is mostly very well written, extraordinarily well acted and skilfully directed by Pam MacKinnon, who paints a pall over the whole production of sick, stale sadness. And yet some moments feel intolerably grim for the sake of it.

Part of the problem is that the play’s salience is lessened in the UK (it was co-commissioned by the National and Chicago’s Steppenwolf Theatre Company). Sex offender registers aren’t publicly available here, capital punishment doesn’t exist, and there’s a huge and hopefully far-reaching inquiry into child sexual abuse ongoing.

That’s not to say it isn’t relevant. Just look at the reaction to the Michael Jackson documentary. Norris tries to unpick this by asking his audience to consider, for example, the differences in a ‘consensual’ relationship between a 37-year-old man and a 14-year-old boy, and the rape of a 12-year-old by his piano teacher.

These men have ankle tags, aren’t allowed to use the internet, aren’t allowed near schools, parks, shops for the rest of their lives. What’s under scrutiny is the line where justice becomes wanton revenge. Norris has mastery over the degree to which we sympathise with these characters. One minute Fred the aged, wheelchair-using, arthritic piano teacher is just a sweet old man; the next he is subtly trying to refocus the victimhood on to himself, even as he faces the guy he abused. Similarly, K Todd Freeman’s slithering Dee is like two characters squished into one: sometimes kind, sometimes unbelievably cruel.

Cecilia Noble is an important centre of the play as Ivy, the police officer in charge of checking up on the offenders. Noble plays her as slow and weary, discommoded at having to do a pretty horrible job, but forceful when she needs to be. She’s patient, but visibly reaching the end of her tether.

Eddie Torres’ Felix, silent and pent-up, is memorable too, clutching his Bible in utter desperation. And watching Tim Hopper’s Andy recounting what his piano teacher did to him is utterly unbearable.

No one is beyond sympathy here, but nor is anyone beyond the reach of Norris’ cynicism and capacity for dramatic cruelty. He gets us to like and to loathe everyone equally.

But he can’t resist comedy, and those moments feel too contrived, and land really hard in such a charged atmosphere. Plus, for all the really finely wrought dialogue, there are clunky scenes too, like the bloated character-building of the second half, which goes nowhere.

Downstate has important points to make, and the quality of the production is undeniable. But does it do enough to justify its graphic descriptions of child rape, its violence, its comedy? It feels too sneering to say, ‘definitively, yes’.

Actor Cecilia Noble: ‘Preparation is everything because then you can fly’

Related to this Review

When We Have Sufficiently Tortured Each OtherWhen We Have Sufficiently Tortured Each Other

Production Details
Production nameDownstate
VenueNational Theatre
StartsMarch 2, 2019
EndsApril 27, 2019
Running time2hrs 30mins
AuthorBruce Norris
DirectorPam Mackinnon
Set designerTodd Rosenthal
Costume designerClint Ramos
Lighting designerAdam Silverman
Sound designerCarolyn Downing
CastAimee Lou Wood, Cecilia Noble, Eddie Torres, Francis Guinan, Glenn Davis, K Todd Freeman, Matilda Ziegler, Tim Hopper
Stage managerAlison Rankin
ProducerNational Theatre, Steppenwolf
VerdictBruce Norris’ harrowing play about child abuse features some superb performances but also sometimes feels cynical
Add New Comment
You must be logged in to comment.
Tim Bano

Tim Bano

Tim Bano

Tim Bano

Your subscription helps ensure our journalism can continue

Invest in The Stage today with a subscription starting at just £3.98
The Stage
© Copyright The Stage Media Company Limited 2020
Linked In