Welcome! This is your first free article. Get more free articles when you sign up with your email.


“A cluttered production”

Massenet’s operatic fairytale is a thing of perfection, his ravishing melodies supported by shimmering solos and feather-light textures. But director Fiona Shaw has thrown a blanket of psychological insights and extraneous symbolism over his delicate construction.

Though the music is never less than beautiful, the production is frantic and full of business; servants run back and forth with shopping, food and ball dresses, until the eye doesn’t know where to focus.

Only in scenes featuring the Fairy Godmother – sung with effortless purity by soprano Caroline Wettergreen, and the ecstatic love duets between the neglected Cendrillon (Alix le Saux) and her depressed Prince, the ardent mezzo-soprano Eleonore Pancrazi, does magic emerge from the muddle.

Le Saux and Pancrazi convince us with their fresh, characterful singing that they are two lonely teenagers who have found their soulmate. Their mystical consummation comes in Act III, when the Fairy Godmother transports them to an enchanted forest – Jon Bausor’s revolving mirrored boxes hiding trees and spirits – and the two women’s voices vibrate with erotic promise.

There are tender exchanges between Cendrillon and her spineless, henpecked father Pandolphe, sympathetically characterised by William Dazeley. But composer and librettist don’t give the wicked stepmother (Agnes Zwierko) and her catty daughters Noemie and Dorothee, (Kezia Bienek and Eduarda Melo) much to get their teeth into.
Zwierko swaggers on in hideous leisurewear but the comedy relies not on her singing, which is low-key, but her striptease down to a corset and Spanx. It’s too broad and pantomime-dame to hit the mark, and the same goes for her daughters, whose only crime is being ugly dressers, not Ugly Sisters.

With a light touch, young conductor Duncan Ward coaxes sensitive, soloistic playing from Glyndebourne Touring Orchestra. If you shut your eyes and savour the interplay between voice and flute, solo violin or celeste – well there’s the magic.

Related to this Review


Production Details
Production nameCendrillon
ComposerJules Massenet
DirectorFiona Shaw
ConductorDuncan Ward
Set designerJon Bausor
Costume designerNicky Gillibrand
Lighting designerAnna Watson
CastAgnes Zwierko, Alix Le Saux, Caroline Wettergreen, Eduarda Melo, Eleonore Pancrazi, Kezia Bienek, William Dazeley
ProducerGlyndebourne Tour 2018
VerdictFiona Shaw’s cluttered production obscures the fairytale magic of Massenet's ravishing opera
Add New Comment
You must be logged in to comment.
Amanda Holloway

Amanda Holloway

Amanda Holloway

Amanda Holloway

Your subscription helps ensure our journalism can continue

Invest in The Stage today with a subscription starting at just £3.98
The Stage
© Copyright The Stage Media Company Limited 2020
Linked In