Kip Williams’ staging for ENO of this Pulitzer-winning work is darkly unforgettable
Chinese-born American composer Du Yun won the 2017 Pulitzer Prize with this opera, directed for English National Opera by Kip Williams.
Royce Vavrek’s libretto tells a dark tale: two angels, young and beautiful, fall to earth and land in the garden of an unhappily married couple in financial straits. Soon, Mr XE (baritone Rodney Earl Clarke) and Mrs XE (soprano Allison Cook) assault them, tearing off their wings to expose the bleeding flesh beneath.
Later, their exploitation of the innocent Girl Angel (the indefinable Mariam Wallentin) and Boy Angel (tenor Matthew McKinney) becomes sexual and financial: their invited guests are allowed to assault/rape them at orgies, for which a donation is charged. Mrs XE carries the Boy Angel’s child.
Eventually, the self-disgusted Mr XE turns, encouraging the angels to escape before (accidentally?) killing himself; his widow, meanwhile, becomes a reality TV celebrity, telling her version of the truth to an adoring public.
Continues...

Treated with a blend of symbolism and realism, the subject explores the troubling, often hidden crimes of modern slavery and sex trafficking, phenomena whose visibility has increased steadily over recent years.
Williams’ staging holds nothing back in its presentation of the horrific narrative. The action takes place in the round, on a circular platform. Marg Horwell’s set visualises the XE’s suburban home and what takes place there in crisp, grisly realism, underlined by three camera operators who simultaneously live-film different scenes, or the same scenes from different angles, projected to the audience on screens. Jack Knowles’ lighting adds considerably to the powerfully disturbing impact.
The chorus – the Kantos Chamber Choir – plays several different roles, from angels singing ancient church music to the orgy’s grasping, sadistic attendees. Their commitment is as obvious as that of the five principals. Cook’s monstrous Mrs XE is a true star performance, voiced with pitiless acerbity.
As her weaker, less implacably evil husband, Earl Clarke offers total conviction. McKinney and Wallentin’s angels are realised in individualised performances that evoke pity and terror.
Du Yun’s score draws on a vast catalogue of mostly contemporary styles, from modernism to electronica, punk rock to cabaret, summoning up a musical counterpart to the fierce, obscene satire on stage. Some sections are more musically memorable than others, but there’s no ignoring the deafening onslaught unleashed at crucial moments by electronic means, which comes close to shaking the building.
This is ENO’s first production to open in the city that is now its second home. Like the chorus, the orchestra is from Manchester – members of the BBC Philharmonic. Conductor Baldur Brönnimann achieves the feat of keeping everything together over the sizable distances involved, punching the score boldly out towards the audience.
In the UK, Samaritans can be contacted via samaritans.org on freephone 116 123
For all the latest opera reviews, news and features, sign up to The Stage’s monthly opera newsletter
Invest in The Stage today with a subscription starting at just £7.99