Welcome! This is your first free article. Get more free articles when you sign up with your email.

An Edinburgh Christmas Carol

“Humour triumphs over humbug”

Director and writer Tony Cownie’s relocation of Charles Dickens’ great Christmas fable to Edinburgh has a real family-friendly feel.

Cownie has married Dickens’ story with that of the city’s best-known canine, Greyfriars Bobby. Scrooge’s office is now located opposite the graveyard where the dog kept vigil on his dead master’s grave. Tiny Tim is the mutt’s best pal, but Scrooge is very much his enemy – along with a vicious dog catcher and Grant O’Rourke’s masterfully comic Policeman.

Crawford Logan brings the necessary humbug to Scrooge, but in everything else – Marley and the ghosts included – there is levity. Belle Jones and Nicola Roy go the furthest, in comic terms, as a pair of Salvation Army sisters collecting for the poor.

Edie Edmundson’s utterly life-like puppet Bobby becomes the story’s focus, somewhat upstaging the puppet Tiny Tim and drawing away from the importance of Taqi Nazeer’s fine but under-used Fred. Cownie’s direction brings real clarity to the tale with all the company, Logan excepted, playing more than one character.

Neil Murray’s set, pitched under Edinburgh Castle and in the Old Town’s towering, overcrowded tenements, adds to the local feel.

Dickens’ basic tale is still intact, if translated into broad Scots, but given the impact of austerity, its social message is surprising diluted. Cownie’s script nods to, but never quite gets around, the historically inconvenient fact that Christmas was not celebrated in Scotland in Victorian times, although the carolling community choir adds a delightful shimmer to the whole piece.

Tartuffe review at Assembly Rooms, Edinburgh – ‘delightful update of Moliere into Scots’

Related to this Review


Production Details
Production nameAn Edinburgh Christmas Carol
VenueRoyal Lyceum Theatre
StartsNovember 28, 2019
EndsJanuary 4, 2020
Running time2hrs 10mins
AuthorTony Cownie
DirectorTony Cownie
Set designerNeil Murray
Costume designerNeil Murray
Lighting designerZoe Spurr
Sound designerPippa Murphy
CastBelle Jones, Crawford Logan, Grant O'Rourke, Nicola Roy, Steven Mcnicoll, Taqi Nazeer, Saskia Ashdow
TechnicalEdie Edmundson
Stage managerDaniel Dixon
ProducerRoyal Lyceum Theatre
VerdictHumour triumphs over humbug in this relocation of Charles Dickens' fable to Victorian Edinburgh
Add New Comment
You must be logged in to comment.
Thom Dibdin

Thom Dibdin

Thom Dibdin

Thom Dibdin

Your subscription helps ensure our journalism can continue

Invest in The Stage today with a subscription starting at just £3.98
The Stage
© Copyright The Stage Media Company Limited 2020
Linked In