Home Truths review at the Bunker, London – ‘patchily panoramic’
Home Truths is Cardboard Citizens’ attempt to tell the history of British housing in nine new short plays.
Cycle One – of three – makes for an engagingly rough-and-ready, patchily panoramic, but tonally inchoate evening, embellished here and there with slideshows, snippets, and real-life stories.
In Sonali Bhattacharyya's Slummers, a 19th-century family of slum-dwelling Milliners desperately try to convince a board of straight-jacketed, late-Victorian philanthropists of their probity. In Heathcote Williams and Sarah Woods' The Ruff Tuff Cream Puff Estate Agency, a rabble of well-meaning radicals match homeless people with empty houses.
In Stef Smith's Back to Back to Back, two intertwining stories – of two couples' anxiety-filled, 30-something lives in adjacent ex-council flats – map out some of the uglier consequences of today's housing crisis, from 'white flight' to 21st century segregation.
A diverse, knockabout cast of 10 - including the impressively versatile Mariam Haque, who shifts between a hard-nosed Eliza Doolittle-esque teenager and a jittery pregnant worrier as the evening unfolds - work hard to ensure each play has a distinct vibe.
The kaleidoscopic Slummers traces the roots of today's social stigmas in the puritanical ignorance of the 1880s elite, while the anarchic Ruff Tuff offers a persuasively heady taste of free-spirited dissent, and the stylishly elliptical Back to Back to Back reaches for a grim, everyday symbolism of discarded mattresses and rising damp.
But for all their worthiness and individual flair, the plays don't form a functioning trio: there's little overarching significance, and an unsettling uncertainty of tone throughout. One never knows whether to laugh or cry, and ends up doing neither.