Get our free email newsletter with just one click

Mark Shenton: Tony Awards underline Broadway’s struggle to house new work

The Broadway production of Harry Potter and the Cursed Child. Photo: Matthew Murphy The Broadway production of Harry Potter and the Cursed Child. Photo: Matthew Murphy
by -

While the Olivier Awards have upped the ante in the glamour stakes by relocating for the last two years to the Royal Albert Hall, New York’s Tony Awards still take some beating in terms of profile and prestige.

Now in their 72nd year, they have, since 1947, been broadcast live on national television, bringing the Great White Way to every village, town, and metropolis far beyond New York for one night a year (and on YouTube forever after). The Oliviers, by comparison, have a highlights package broadcast on ITV after the event.

The Tonys are truly synonymous with Broadway, as a gold standard of officially anointed excellence that not only translates into giving the rewarded shows a local branding but also an international one.

‘All four writers nominated for best book of a musical were making their debuts’

Most of the titles in contention for this year’s awards were brand names already, from the global franchises of Harry Potter and Disney’s Frozen to another animated cartoon title SpongeBob SquarePants, the film Mean Girls and revivals of two golden-age musicals, My Fair Lady and Carousel.

But, as shows seem to run ever longer, the pool of available real estate for new shows gets smaller with each new hit. So, this year’s winners are drawn from one of the most exclusive lists in Tony history: the paltry listing of 30 eligible new productions to have opened across the season. That’s a 25% drop on the previous year’s 40 openings – and a marked difference from the 1927/28 season, which predates the Tonys, when there were a whopping 264 openings, including 183 new plays and 53 new musicals.

As Broadway commentator Jeremy Gerard said in a recent column for Broadway News: “Today’s Broadway is looking more and more like the long-term leasing business.”

With the arrival of this year’s new long-term properties, some 26 of the 41 designated Broadway theatres are booked for the foreseeable future.

Tony glory accentuates this trend, extending the runs of its winners and giving them national touring legs for the all-important regional circuit.

But Broadway is also famously a disrupter as well as a consolidator of existing trends, reinventing the genre it provides a home to, as well as welcoming new talent.

American Theatre Wing: The women behind the Tony Awards

Among the latter, according to playbill.com, of the 130 Tony-nominated artists this year, 59 are first-time nominees, and 34 of them made their Broadway debuts. All four writers nominated for best book of a musical were making their debuts: Itamar Moses (who took home the award for The Band’s Visit), Jennifer Lee (Frozen), Tina Fey (Mean Girls) and Kyle Jarrow (SpongeBob SquarePants).

But it is perhaps significant that the headline winner this year was The Band’s Visit – taking nine other awards, including best musical. Though based on a film, it was not a blockbuster with immediate title recognition or a cult following, but a relatively unsung 2007 Israeli comedy-drama about an Egyptian ceremonial police orchestra who arrive to play at a cultural centre in Israel, only to discover they have come to the wrong place. It is a delicately textured, quirky musical about outsiders that disarms with its gentle romanticism and lyricism.

As a result of its success, it knocked the other principal front-runners out of the competition almost entirely. Mean Girls, which had 12 nominations, went away empty handed, while SpongeBob SquarePants, which also had 12 nominations, only turned one of them into a win (for David Zinn’s scenic design).

Meanwhile, one of the biggest surprises of the night was the triumph of the new production of the 1990 Ahrens and Flaherty musical Once on This Island, which was named best musical revival over the competing claims of two golden age classics, My Fair Lady and Carousel.

On the plays front, the Tonys generally matter less commercially speaking than the musical awards, since they are not typically booked for open-ended runs, but this year was an exception with the arrival of Harry Potter and the Cursed Child.

‘Broadway is also famously a disrupter as well as a consolidator of existing trends’

At a reported cost of some $58.5 million to bring it to New York (including $33 million to clear out and refurbish the theatre it is housed in), it is the most expensive play in Broadway history. As New York Times theatre reporter Michael Paulson put it: “It’s a huge bet in a flop-prone industry, but also a seemingly safe one, predicated on the expectation that Cursed Child will become a big hit on Broadway, a long-running production that can spin off profits for years.”

It is also a brilliant show and the Tonys recognised that with six awards, including best play. Its winners were among a strong showing of British onstage and offstage talent that also saw Glenda Jackson’s Broadway return, in Edward Albee’s Three Tall Women, win her the leading actress award and dual citizen Andrew Garfield (US-born but raised in Britain) win the leading actor award for Angels in America. That show, originated at the National Theatre before transferring to Broadway, also took Tonys for best revival of a play and for Nathan Lane as best featured actor.

The other big British win of the night was a lifetime achievement award for Andrew Lloyd Webber, capping a year in which he has turned 70 and published the first volume of his autobiography. But undoubtedly the most poignant award of the night was for Melody Herzfeld, a drama teacher at Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School in Texas, which was the scene of the terrible massacre in February. She received the annual Tony for excellence in theatre education. Collecting it, she said: “We all have a common energy. We all want the same thing. To be heard. To tell our truth. To make a difference. And to be respected. We teach this every day in every arts class.”

Her students have carried this message to the world. At the Tonys, they proved it, too, performing ‘Seasons of Love’ from the musical Rent.

We need your help…

When you subscribe to The Stage, you’re investing in our journalism. And our journalism is invested in supporting theatre and the performing arts.

The Stage is a family business, operated by the same family since we were founded in 1880. We do not receive government funding. We are not owned by a large corporation. Our editorial is not dictated by ticket sales.

We are fully independent, but this means we rely on revenue from readers to survive.

Help us continue to report on great work across the UK, champion new talent and keep up our investigative journalism that holds the powerful to account. Your subscription helps ensure our journalism can continue.