Adam Penford: ‘It’s hard to convince stars to leave London, but there’s a way’

One Man, Two Guvnors with Rufus Hound. Photo: Tristram Kenton Adam Penford, artistic director of Nottingham Playhouse. Photo: Creative by Wren

New artistic director Adam Penford is looking forward to putting the Nottingham Playhouse back on the map. He tells Lyn Gardner about capturing the anarchic spirit of his home city, enticing high-profile actors including Mark Gatiss to his stage and why he is happy that his career trajectory has been a slow burn

Every Christmas when he was growing up in Nottingham, Adam Penford’s parents took him to the Playhouse panto. One year, Penford was one of the children invited up on to the stage but was too shy. He immediately regretted his lack of courage. “Every year after that, I waited for them to ask me again. But they never did,” he says wistfully.

Penford no longer needs to be asked to step on to the Nottingham Playhouse stage. He is running it. The theatre’s new artistic director designate – succeeding Giles Croft, who steps down after his final production at the end of the year after almost two decades – unveiled his first season this week. It includes the tasty prospect of Mark Gatiss playing the monarch in a revival of Alan Bennett’s The Madness of King George III.

The Playhouse announced Penford had landed his dream job last November – he started in July – but there was a moment during his final interview when he thought he might have blown the opportunity.

“I had to present a theoretical first season to the panel. I had spent hours preparing a PowerPoint presentation and when I plugged my laptop into the projector it wiped my hard drive. I saw the look on the panels’ faces, they were just as horrified as me. It was worst-case scenario,” he says. But Penford was able to turn disaster to his advantage: “I had spent so long preparing that I knew the whole thing inside out. I really wouldn’t recommend it as an interview technique, but I don’t suppose it hurt that I reacted well under pressure.”

Building blocks

About half of that theoretical first season will become a reality as part of Penford’s announcement. If the casting of Gatiss represents the ambition Penford has for Nottingham, it may mark a turning point for the venue. Despite successes under Croft, the Playhouse has not had the sense of purpose of some of its immediate neighbours. Penford, who is well connected after several years as Nicholas Hytner’s associate at the National, says he is determined to “put it back on the map”.

It is necessary at a time when regional theatre is facing local authority cuts and stand-still funding. And at a time when buildings are under pressure to define their purpose, their role in the community and what they offer to both audiences and local artists. Nearby Sheffield Theatres had a distinct fizz and glitz under Daniel Evans, whose work Penford admires enormously; Derby Theatre has been reinvented as a learning theatre under Sarah Brigham and is a significant supporter of young talent.

After a tricky start, the Curve in Leicester has settled into a mixed programme and is making a name as a try-out venue for musicals with wider aspirations. These include the successful adaptation of Sue Townsend’s Adrian Mole and the recently announced An Officer and a Gentleman.

It’s no bad thing that Penford has looked at what others are doing well and what they are getting right.


Q&A: Adam Penford

What was your first job? Box office at Riverside Studios for nine years. It paid the rent.

What was your first directing job? Young Woodley and Tea and Sympathy at London’s Finborough in 2006.

What do you wish someone had told you when you were starting out? There’s no point in comparing yourself to someone else – everyone’s career path is different.

Who or what was your biggest influence? Nicholas Hytner.

What’s your best advice for auditions? Preparation. I’m amazed by how many actors turn up at auditions without really preparing.

If you hadn’t been a director, what would you have been? Working in theatre in some capacity.

Do you have any theatrical superstitions or rituals? No, I don’t believe in them, and I dislike them. People rely on them too much and they have a negative effect. In One Man, Two Guvnors, James Corden had to toss a peanut into the air and catch it in the first 10 minutes of the show. It always got a round of applause, and if he ever missed he’d believe it was going to be a really bad show, and that was passed on to the subsequent casts. I thought that was complete rubbish.

On his very first day in the job he instigated a new programme for artist development, and one of the plays in the first season is Mufaro Makubika’s Shebeen, directed by Matthew Xia. It is set during the 1958 race riots that sparked in Nottingham prior to the more widely documented Notting Hill riots.

Nottingham-born playwright Beth Steel’s 2014 play, Wonderland – previously staged at Hampstead Theatre and inspired by her father’s experience down the pits during the Thatcher years – is also in a season that shoots for diversity in terms of gender, race and disability.

Three out of the eight productions are written by women and include Diane Samuels’ Kindertransport and Timberlake Wertenbaker’s modern classic, Our Country’s Good. The latter will boast a fully integrated cast and creative team of disabled and non-disabled practitioners and is a co-production with Ramps on the Moon. In future, Penford will aim for a 50/50 gender split.

Penford has been undeterred from programming musical theatre despite the Playhouse’s proximity to the musical-heavy Curve, and the presence of the Theatre Royal, a receiving house just around the corner which gets touring shows such as Crazy for You and Beautiful. Penford’s debut season includes the revival of Sweet Charity, to be directed by Bill Buckhurst, whose Tooting Arts Club version of Sweeney Todd in a 109-year-old pie and mash shop transferred to the West End and then New York. The show will be choreographed by rising star Alistair David, who did such a good job at Chichester on Daniel Evans’ Fiddler on the Roof.

“I am passionate about musicals, and it’s great to see everyone in the building excited about doing one, particularly the technical staff,” Penford says. “It’s a gamble. It’s bloody expensive. But it can pay off. There is a crossover audience for musicals. Look at what Daniel did with those Christmas musicals in Sheffield. People travelled far and wide to see those and they had commercial possibilities.” He clearly wants some of that commercial clout for Nottingham.

“Nottingham has had its successes with show such as The Kite Runner, and we were co-producers on Headlong’s 1984. But we need to have broader horizons. People often think about co-productions in terms of splitting the costs, but actually it’s about sharing the work and getting it seen more widely. We need to make bold, great work and we also need to take Nottingham’s work out of Nottingham by making partnerships with other regional theatres, commercial producers or London theatres.”

Setting realistic goals

He reckons it’s essential, not least because he wants to attract more high-profile actors such as Gatiss – with whom he recently worked on the London run and tour of The Boys in the Band – as well as directors and designers who are more likely to be found in London than the regions.

“It’s about how you change the offer to them, and it’s not easy. Our fees don’t match those of the NT or the Donmar. It’s a vicious circle. Lots of young directors and designers know that their work won’t be reviewed regionally so if they have a choice between directing at the Bush or Nottingham, they will go for the former because they will get national reviews,” he says.

Mark Gatiss will play the monarch in a revival of Alan Bennett’s The Madness of King George III
Mark Gatiss will play the monarch in a revival of Alan Bennett’s The Madness of King George III

“With actors, it is hard to get people to commit as far in advance as a regional theatre needs because they don’t want to rule themselves out of an offer that might come up from the NT or Netflix. I understand that. I also understand that the money isn’t great. But you can give people a reason to come. I just had a feeling that Mark (Gatiss) wouldn’t be able to resist The Madness of George III.”

For Penford, the allure of Nottingham was the chance to run his own theatre, particularly one with such a rich history – the roll call of artistic directors includes Richard Eyre and John Neville. It is a city he knows intimately, whose people, he says, are characterised by “an anarchic spirit”.

“There is so much potential here,” he adds. “A real capacity to grow and diversify an audience. My aim is to offer a varied and deliberately populist programme of work. The panto has an incredibly diverse audience, but the challenge is getting that audience back through the doors over the rest of the year.”

It’s one of the reasons for doing Sweet Charity, but also for putting on a family show– a stage adaptation of Louis Sachar’s brilliant novel of friendship and race, Holes, which Penford will direct using puppetry and music – right at the centre of the first season’s offer.

But if securing the artistic directorship of Nottingham Playhouse marks a homecoming for Penford (he didn’t tell his parents who still live in the city that he was going for the job until he actually got it), it has been via a circuitous route.

Penford, whose mother was a primary school teacher and father a painter and decorator, had no theatre connections growing up. It wasn’t until he joined the local youth theatre that he developed any interest in the stage and started going to see everything at the Playhouse. When somebody else in the youth theatre got a place at the Liverpool Institute for Performing Arts, he decided to audition on a whim.

He was successful. But within weeks of arriving he realised that he didn’t want to be an actor. “Actually, he was a very good actor,” says Donna Soto-Morettini, his acting coach at LIPA, and one of the people Penford credits with helping him find his true vocation as a director. “But he was always uncertain of himself as an actor,” she adds, saying that even so: “You could tell he was a theatre animal, and knew how to tell a good story.” Soto-Morettini and others at LIPA encouraged Penford to direct. His final project was a production of Terence Rattigan’s The Winslow Boy, an early indication of an interest in sturdy, well-made plays that have tended to go out of fashion among young directors hoping to make their mark.


Adam Penford on…

… artistic directors
Most artistic directors have quite a strong sense of civic duty. Otherwise, why would they want to do the job? Running a building isn’t easy. There’s also a strong desire to want to nurture and develop an audience and take them on a journey with you.

… the benefit of local knowledge
The real advantage of coming from Nottingham, and the fact my parents still live there, is that I’m going to know what the opinion is on the ground about the Playhouse. It could prove invaluable. I already know in great detail what everyone thinks about the food on offer.

… funding for the arts
I don’t need to make the argument for the arts or for regional theatre. I know what the Playhouse did for me growing up. It gave me an education. We need to do that for future generations too and that means doing whatever is necessary and looking to other ways to support these buildings – through sponsorship and philanthropy – to ensure their survival.

There are plenty of Penford’s contemporaries – including Jamie Lloyd, who was also at LIPA – who have had more stellar careers, but Penford is not complaining.

“Mine has been much more slow-burning. Although I’ve seen many of my contemporaries’ careers fly, I’ve also seen lots of people fall by the wayside,” he says.

“I never had the levels of ambition that some of my contemporaries have had. I’ve always been happy to be working and going from job to job as long as I feel I’m moving forward in some way. I’ve never massively worried about the pace of it.”

Committee featuring Sandra Marvin as Camila Batmanghelidjh and Omar Ebrahim as Alan Yentob, at the Donmar Warehouse. Photo: Manuel Harlan
Committee featuring Sandra Marvin as Camila Batmanghelidjh and Omar Ebrahim as Alan Yentob, at the Donmar Warehouse. Photo: Manuel Harlan

It’s certainly encompassed a broad range of work. His most recent production was the verbatim musical about the collapsed Kids’ Company – Committee – at the Donmar Warehouse in London, but over the last couple of years he was as likely to be found doing Deathtrap in Salisbury or a terrific robust revival of Watership Down in Newbury.

Surely over the years he has looked at others making a name for themselves and sometimes felt frustrated? “Honestly, no,” he says – and I believe him.

“I’ve always liked doing it all and I’ve made choices, and maybe sometimes they weren’t the choices that were best for my career. But they allowed me to do lots of different kinds of work. I have very eclectic tastes, I’m equally passionate about musicals as I am about family and children’s shows [he was an associate at the Polka for several years]. Maybe I would have climbed quicker by specialising in a particular area, but what I’ve done has made me happy.”

That includes spending several years at the NT as an associate director under Nicholas Hytner. “It opened a lot of doors. I got to take One Man, Two Guvnors to Broadway, into the West End and around the world. I was the associate director on the NT’s 50th-anniversary gala. I can’t tell you how lucky I was to be in that rehearsal room. I was around the building so I got to see how it worked. I was involved in development and participation. I learned such a lot. I got my own show in the Olivier.”

One Man, Two Guvnors with Rufus Hound. Photo: Tristram Kenton
One Man, Two Guvnors with Rufus Hound. Photo: Tristram Kenton

That show was the 2014 revival of Alan Ayckbourn’s A Small Family Business and Penford is the first to admit it didn’t fly as intended. “It was originally supposed to be in the Lyttelton. I had worked there as a resident, I knew it inside out. But it was moved to the ‘Ollie’. I couldn’t argue about it. It was the space Ayckbourn had written it for and where he had directed it himself.

“And yet, the thing I love about Ayckbourn is that it’s so intimate. In rehearsals, we had a great time. The minute you put it on the Ollie stage you have a choice: do you inflate it and lose the nuance or do you put it on at the level you were playing it at and fail to hit the back of the auditorium? I suspect what I did was go somewhere between the two so it didn’t become an out-and-out farce or a beautifully nuanced study of a family.”

Staying true

He says he has no way of knowing if it negatively affected his career. “I genuinely don’t know if it was damaging. Of course, if it had been a five-star smash I’m sure I would have been offered lots of other jobs. As it was, that didn’t happen.”

He certainly doesn’t think it contributed to him leaving the NT. “No, it was about Nick leaving and Rufus [Norris] coming in and quite rightly wanting to give those opportunities to the artists he had a relationship with. I was just part of a general change in the building, which was quite right. I don’t feel bad about it. That is what I am about to do in Nottingham.

“There will be people who have a long-standing relationship with Nottingham and feel passionately about it but who will have to make way for the artists I want to attract and bring into the building. That is just part of regime change. It’s healthy for the organisation and it’s healthy for the sector.”

It’s this mixture of pragmatism, good sense and a generosity of spirit that makes Penford such a likeable character. He’s clearly no pushover, but he also seems genuinely a bit stunned that “the stars aligned” to drop the Nottingham job into his lap. A couple of days before we met he had returned to LIPA to give the alumni address. What did he tell them?

“I was very up front about the fact that in my early years I was often competing with Oxbridge graduates for jobs and they often had the kind of self-belief that I didn’t because I came from a very different background. One of the things I’ve realised over the years is that self-belief doesn’t always translate into being a good practitioner. It’s better to stay true to yourself.”

CV Adam Penford

Born: 1980, Nottingham
Training: LIPA
Landmark productions: One Man, Two Guvnors (revival director, touring production, 2014); A Small Family Business, National Theatre (2014); Deathtrap, Salisbury Playhouse (2016); Watership Down, Watermill Theatre, Newbury (2016); The Boys in the Band, Park Theatre, London (2016); Committee, Donmar Warehouse (2017)
Agent: St John Donald, United Agents