Last update less than

What's On


The Doctor’s Dilemma

Published Wednesday 25 July 2012 at 10:40 by Jonathan Lovett

In his preface to a damning satire on the medical profession Shaw labelled it a “murderous absurdity”.

Genevieve O'Reilly (Jennifer Dubedat) and Tom Burke (Dubedat) in The Doctor's Dilemma at the Lyttelton, National Theatre, London

Genevieve O'Reilly (Jennifer Dubedat) and Tom Burke (Dubedat) in The Doctor's Dilemma at the Lyttelton, National Theatre, London Photo: Tristram Kenton

His main beef was the quackery of the time where private doctors were charging small fortunes for pointless operations but it has since transcended its era to apply to anytime - particularly pertinent now - where profit is put before the patient’s good.

On a ravishing Edwardian set Nadia Fall’s production brilliantly resurrects the 1906 drama as a play for today, never pressing the parallels but elegantly presenting Shaw as a prescient commentator with a wicked sense of humour in the face of death.

Slightly pompous, Sir Colenso Ridgeon (Aden Gillett) believes he has discovered a new treatment that can cure tuberculosis. Enchanted by a young lady (Genevieve O’Reilly) who arrives begging him to cure her husband (Tom Burke) he has to decide whether this genius artist of dubious reputation is worth saving over lesser, but perhaps more reputable, souls.

That is just one of a host of dilemmas confronting the doctor, the audience and the director with the latter having to decide whether this is a comedy or tragedy and wisely plumping for both.

Ridgeon’s three eminent doctor friends provide most of these laughs and a quartet at the top of their game spark off each other to create an invigorating tonic. Gillett, Malcolm Sinclair, David Calder and Robert Portal send up their self-important characters without slipping into caricature to prove this one of Shaw’s funniest plays, while Burke performs the tricky feat of making us care for a dislikeable rogue who is ultimately a pawn in a morbid medical conspiracy.

Production information

Lyttelton, London, July 24-September 12

George Bernard Shaw
Nadia Fall
National Theatre
Aden Gillett, Tom Burke, David Calder, Robert Portal, Malcolm Sinclair, Genevieve O'Reilly, Maggie McCarthy, William Belchambers, Paul Herzberg, Derek Hutchinson, Amy Hall, Jonathan Coote, Samuel Taylor, Richard Teverson, Callum Coates, Aimee Parkes, Joseph Wilkins
Running time:
2hrs 50mins

Production information displayed was believed correct at time of review. Information may change over the run of the show.

Search Amazon for The Doctor's Dilemma items Search for tickets at Ticketmaster

Run sheet

King's Head, Islington London
January 24-February 15 2014